Animal Welfare

Denmark Bans Slaughter Without Stunning? What the Viral Post Gets Right and Wrong

Denmark requires stunning before every slaughter, but it has done so since 2014. How Europe and Germany handle it, and why a stunning requirement alone does not prevent animal suffering.

Close-up of a light grey cow with two ear tags looking straight into the camera
A cow with ear tags. Stock photo: Stephen Leonardi / Pexels

A claim is doing the rounds on social media that Denmark “now” requires stunning before every slaughter. That’s true, but it isn’t new. Denmark scrapped the exemption for slaughter without stunning on religious grounds back in February 2014. By then, nobody had used it for around ten years. The question at the end of the post still deserves an answer, though: is a stunning requirement enough to prevent animal suffering at slaughter?

Werbe-Hinweis: Dieser Artikel enthält Affiliate-Links. Kaufst du über einen dieser Links, erhalten wir eine kleine Provision. Für dich ändert sich am Preis nichts. So finanzieren wir die Redaktion und bleiben unabhängig. Danke für deinen Support.

In short

  • True, but old: Denmark has required stunning without a religious exemption since February 17, 2014.
  • What’s still allowed: Halal slaughter with prior stunning, and importing meat from animals slaughtered without stunning.
  • Europe: Sweden, Norway, Iceland, Switzerland, Slovenia and Belgium also ban slaughter without stunning. European courts have upheld such bans.
  • Germany: Exemptions on religious grounds are possible there.
  • Is it enough? No. Even with a stunning requirement, some animals are not properly stunned at slaughter.
Close-up of a light grey cow with two ear tags looking straight into the camera
A cow with ear tags. Stock photo: Stephen Leonardi / Pexels
Contents6 chapters
  1. 01What the rules in Denmark say
  2. 02How Europe handles it
  3. 03And in Germany
  4. 04Why stunning makes a difference
  5. 05Is it enough? Stunning often fails
  6. 06An animal ethics perspective

What the rules in Denmark say.

The rule goes back to an executive order issued by then agriculture minister Dan Jørgensen in February 2014. Since February 17, 2014, all animals in Denmark have to be stunned before slaughter, including in religious slaughter. Today this is set out in the executive order on the killing of animals from 2023. Religious slaughter is only allowed with prior stunning, only for cattle, sheep, goats and broiler chickens, only in a slaughterhouse and only after notifying the food authority.

In practice, little changed in 2014. According to a record of the Danish parliament, there had been no slaughter without stunning since 2004, when the last slaughterhouse offering it closed. Finn Schwarz, president of the Jewish community, told the Jewish Telegraphic Agency at the time that the last shechita in the country had been more than ten years earlier. His main criticism was how the minister justified the decision.

Jørgensen was quoted as saying that animal rights come before religion. He later said he had been misquoted, the Copenhagen Post reported. The umbrella organisation Danish Halal collected around 20,000 signatures and called the rule a clear violation of religious freedom, according to FoodNavigator. Meat from animals slaughtered abroad without stunning can still be imported and sold.

Nothing new has been added in Denmark since. A motion by the right-wing populist Danish People’s Party to ban the production, import and sale of all halal products failed in parliament in 2025.

How Europe handles it.

In the EU, Regulation 1099/2009 generally requires animals to be stunned before slaughter. It allows an exemption for religious slaughter, but lets member states adopt stricter rules. In December 2020, the Court of Justice of the EU ruled that a country may require reversible stunning, which does not kill the animals, even for religious slaughter without violating freedom of religion (press release, PDF). In February 2024, the European Court of Human Rights upheld the bans in Belgium (judgment).

Besides Denmark, Sweden, Norway, Iceland, Switzerland and Slovenia ban slaughter without stunning, and in Belgium the ban applies in Flanders and Wallonia, according to an overview by the US Commission on International Religious Freedom. Switzerland has had its ban since 1893, but meat from abroad may be imported.

The best of the magazine, once a week

New tests, recipes and real research, plus the discount codes from our partners. Free, unsubscribe any time.

And in Germany.

Stunning is generally required here too. But Section 4a of the German Animal Welfare Act allows exemptions where mandatory rules of a religious community require slaughter without stunning. In 2002, the Federal Constitutional Court sided with a Muslim butcher who had sued for such a permit (press release, in German). How many permits authorities grant is not recorded nationwide.

Brown and white cattle standing on a green pasture under a blue sky, looking at the camera
Cattle on a pasture on the island of Fur, Denmark. Stock photo: alona sees / Pexels

Why stunning makes a difference.

In slaughter without stunning, the animals’ throats are cut while they are fully conscious. They only lose consciousness through blood loss. In cattle, this takes between 14 seconds and more than two minutes, according to a review by Wageningen University. In a British study of 174 cattle, the animals collapsed after 20 seconds on average, and eight percent only after a minute or longer. The European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) recommends always stunning animals before the cut (opinion on cattle). Researchers from Israel, on the other hand, conclude in a review that cattle lose consciousness quickly.

Is it enough? Stunning often fails.

The stunning requirement covers almost all animals slaughtered in Europe, and plenty goes wrong there too. In a field study in slaughterhouses, an average of 13.5 percent of cattle showed signs of insufficient stunning after the captive bolt, with large differences between plants. For pigs, the share ranged from 3.2 to 12.5 percent depending on the method, and was 7.5 percent with CO2 stunning.

CO2 stunning is controversial in itself. In the gas, pigs struggle to breathe and panic before they lose consciousness. EFSA lists pain, fear and respiratory distress as consequences (opinion on pigs). An advisory committee to the UK government recommended in 2025 phasing out the method within five years (opinion).

An animal ethics perspective.

A stunning requirement without exemptions is better for the animals than none. Bleeding out while conscious means suffering for longer. Still, the debate about religious slaughter often distracts from the bigger problem. It concerns a small share of animals, and it is not rarely conducted with an undertone against religious minorities that has little to do with animal welfare.

For a cow or a pig, the journey ends at the slaughterhouse either way, stunned or not. The figures on failed stunning show that “humane” slaughter is often anything but gentle in everyday practice. So the more honest answer to the question in the post is this: stunning can reduce suffering, but it doesn’t make killing harmless. Why we treat some species so differently from others is covered in our piece on speciesism, and psychologist Melanie Joy explains why we love some animals and eat others in her book on carnism*.

How we researched this

This article was prompted by a social media post presenting the Danish rule as new. We checked the current Danish executive order (BEK no. 817 of 2023), records of the Danish parliament and reports from 2014. We did not find any new rule from 2025 or 2026. Information on the EU legal framework comes from the rulings of the CJEU and the ECtHR, figures on failed stunning from a field study published in the journal Animal Welfare in 2012. Dan Jørgensen’s quote is only known from media reports, and he later disputed it. We have no business relationships with the organisations mentioned.

* Affiliate link: if you buy through this link, we earn a small commission. The price stays the same for you.

Want our reporting to show up first in Google's Top Stories? Add This Is Vegan as a preferred source on Google.