News

Plant or Animal Protein for Building Muscle? Three New Studies Checked

Three recent studies compare plant and animal protein for strength training. The difference is small and shows up mostly in older adults.

Woman in sportswear gripping a barbell with green plates in a gym, ready to deadlift
Strength training with a barbell. Stock photo: Anastasia Shuraeva / Pexels

Does plant protein build less muscle than milk, eggs or meat? On paper, there are reasons to think so. Three recent studies have now looked at the question in people who lift. The result: the difference is small, and it shows up mostly in older adults. Dutch fitness author Menno Henselmans summed up the studies in an Instagram post. We read all three in the original.

Werbe-Hinweis: Dieser Artikel enthält Affiliate-Links. Kaufst du über einen dieser Links, erhalten wir eine kleine Provision. Für dich ändert sich am Preis nichts. So finanzieren wir die Redaktion und bleiben unabhängig. Danke für deinen Support.

In short

  • Muscle mass: A meta-analysis of five trials found no significant difference between soy or pea protein and whey in people new to strength training.
  • Muscle protein synthesis: In older adults, 20 grams of corn protein or a pea and corn blend worked just as well after a workout as 20 grams of milk protein.
  • The big picture: A review of twelve studies sees a tiny edge for animal protein, mainly from age 65. In younger adults there was no visible difference.
  • In everyday life: If you eat enough protein from a variety of sources, where it comes from hardly matters.
  • Limits: All three papers rest on few studies or small groups, and one was funded by an agribusiness company.
Woman in sportswear gripping a barbell with green plates in a gym, ready to deadlift
How well plant protein works for strength training has been studied for years. Stock photo: Anastasia Shuraeva / Pexels
Contents6 chapters
  1. 01Why plant protein is seen as weaker
  2. 02Study 1: soy and pea vs. whey
  3. 03Study 2: corn and pea vs. milk
  4. 04Study 3: twelve studies, a tiny lead
  5. 05What this means for your training
  6. 06An animal ethics perspective

Why plant protein is seen as weaker.

The doubts have a basis. On average, plant protein is a little less digestible, and its mix of essential amino acids matches human muscle less closely. The one people mention most is leucine, an amino acid that switches on muscle building after training. Milk protein is rich in it, many plant proteins have less. There are exceptions: corn is relatively high in leucine, and soy has a well-balanced profile.

Researchers capture this with scores like DIAAS, which combines digestibility and amino acid profile. Animal proteins usually score higher. What stayed open for a long time was how much of that gap actually reaches the muscle when people train.

Study 1: soy and pea vs. whey.

A team at São Paulo State University (UNESP) in Brazil published a meta-analysis in the Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition at the end of October. It pooled five randomized trials with untrained adults aged 18 to 59 who started strength training and took either a plant protein powder or whey. Body composition was measured by DEXA scan, an X-ray method that tells muscle and fat mass apart.

Both groups gained lean mass and lost fat. The researchers found no statistically significant difference between plant and animal protein, for lean mass or for fat mass. They conclude that soy and pea protein are a practical alternative to whey. Chia protein appeared in only one study, and it showed no gain in lean mass.

The evidence has limits, though. Only 181 people went into the lean mass analysis, and the authors themselves write that the data are not enough to prove physiological equivalence. Henselmans also points out that protein doses were not always equal. He’s right: in one of the five trials the soy group got 26 grams of protein and the whey group 19 grams. That study matched leucine content, not total protein.

The best of the magazine, once a week

New tests, recipes and real research, plus the discount codes from our partners. Free, unsubscribe any time.

Study 2: corn and pea vs. milk.

The second paper comes from Stuart Phillips’ lab at McMaster University in Canada, with Luc van Loon’s group in Maastricht also on board. Both are among the best-known names in protein research. The study in the Journal of Nutrition came out on October 26.

48 healthy older adults, 68 years old on average, trained one leg on a leg extension machine and then drank 20 grams of corn protein, a pea and corn blend, milk protein or a protein-free placebo. Using a tracer in the blood and muscle biopsies, the researchers measured how much new muscle protein the body built.

All three proteins raised muscle protein synthesis far more than the placebo: corn by 216 percent, the pea and corn blend by 217 percent and milk by 138 percent over baseline. There was no significant difference between the three proteins. Training boosted the effect further in every group.

Two caveats belong here. With twelve people per group the study is small, and it measures a single workout, which says nothing about muscle growth over months. According to the Europe PMC database, the work was funded by US agribusiness company Cargill.

Tofu cubes on a plate next to scattered dried soybeans on white marble
Soy has one of the most balanced amino acid profiles among plant proteins. Stock photo: Polina Tankilevitch / Pexels

Study 3: twelve studies, a tiny lead.

The largest of the three is a meta-analysis in the Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, online since late April and in print in the September issue. Its authors include hypertrophy researcher Brad Schoenfeld and statistician Paul Swinton. They pooled twelve studies that compared muscle protein synthesis after plant and animal protein in healthy adults.

Across all ages, animal protein came out slightly ahead. At 0.004, though, the effect was so small that it sits within the range of normal fasting protein synthesis, and the uncertainty interval reaches below zero. In people aged 65 and over the edge was a bit clearer. In younger adults, muscle responded similarly to both sources. Whether people trained or not made no visible difference, but there was little data on that.

One thing matters for reading this: the animal side was almost always milk protein, the plant side a mix of soy, pea, wheat, potato and other sources. The authors warn against applying the result to all proteins. Henselmans notes that this analysis, too, includes a study in which the plant group got more protein. We could not check that in the abstract.

What this means for your training.

The theory still holds: gram for gram, animal protein is often a little more efficient in the lab. In practice the gap shrinks once there is enough protein on your plate and it comes from several sources. Henselmans reaches the same conclusion in his post.

On amounts, the guidance is clear. In its position stand, the International Society of Sports Nutrition recommends 1.4 to 2.0 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight per day for most people who exercise. The sports nutrition working group of the German Nutrition Society lands on 1.2 to 2.0 grams in its statement and sees little extra benefit for muscle mass above about 1.6 grams. If you eat vegan, aim for the upper end and combine legumes, soy, grains, nuts and seeds. We cover the evidence in more depth in our guide to vegan muscle building and in our article on protein for vegan athletes.

For protein powder, blends of several plants make sense because their amino acid profiles complement each other. Henselmans recommends a pea and rice blend at 80 to 20. We could not find the protein quality score he gives for it in any primary source. Why rice protein works well in blends is explained in our rice protein guide. Blends like the 3K protein powder from Nutri+* combine pea, soy and sunflower. If you’re older, pay particular attention to getting enough protein per meal, because that’s where the data show the biggest gap.

An animal ethics perspective.

Almost every one of these studies measures plant protein against milk protein. Milk is the yardstick everything else has to beat. Behind every scoop of whey there is a cow who is inseminated year after year so that she keeps giving milk, and a calf who is taken from her shortly after birth. Whey is a by-product of cheese making and so depends on exactly this system.

The lead the largest review measures for animal protein is in the thousandths. One Instagram user put it well under Henselmans’ post: even if animal protein were superior, that would not justify choosing it over plant protein. If you build muscle on soy, peas and lentils, based on what we know today you give up practically nothing. For the animals, that choice changes everything.

How we researched this

This article was prompted by an Instagram post by Menno Henselmans on November 17, 2026. We identified the three studies he refers to via PubMed and checked his claims against the originals. We read the meta-analysis by Callegari et al. in the open-access full text. For the studies by Lim et al. and Mendes et al. we only had the abstracts, as the full texts are behind a paywall. Funding information comes from Europe PMC. Protein recommendations come from the 2017 ISSN position stand and the 2020 statement of the German Nutrition Society’s sports nutrition working group. This article does not replace individual nutrition advice. We have no business relationships with the study authors or with Menno Henselmans.

* Affiliate link: if you buy through this link, we earn a small commission. The price stays the same for you.

Want our reporting to show up first in Google's Top Stories? Add This Is Vegan as a preferred source on Google.